Manga One Piece was put into battles or conflicts by the author Oda, ranging from conflicts in the lives of the Straw Hat crew members to the plan to overthrow the dictatorial Shichibukai to save a country.
Among them were two far more dominant developments culminating in an all-out battle between the opposing factions – the Battle of the Summit at Marineford and the raid on Onigashima in Wano.
Although both have different beginnings and endings, which fight will be appreciated when comparing other factors such as outstanding characters, intense confrontations or compelling situations? Engage the audience in every detail.
These Arcs all lead to important changes in the plot and show the true power of the Yonko in the New World. Let’s analyze the main factors to evaluate which Arc is superior from the perspective of VietOtaku.
The main forces involved in the war
Marineford features the largest forces of One Piece on both sides. On one side is the Whitebeard Yonko crew with 16 teams led by elite commanders and 46 powerful pirate crews as their allies in the New World.
In addition, Luffy and his friends successfully escaped Impel Down and promptly joined the battle at Marineford, including the Clown Buggy, Jinbei and the former Shichibukai Crocodile.
At the other end of the battle line is a collection of powerful navy aces including three Admirals Kizaru, Aokiji, Akainu and Seamaster Admiral Sengoku and Vice Admiral Monkey D. Garp.
Not only that, on the same side as them are the Shichibukai with illustrious reputations such as the World’s Strongest Swordsman Mihawk and Pirate Queen Boa Hancock. The events of this Summit Battle were filmed and broadcast live around the world.
The war in Wano is equally interesting with the confrontation between the alliance of two Yonko Kaido – Big Mom and an allied force including the Straw Hats – The Samurai of Wano – The Minks – The two members of the Worst Generation is Kid and Law – Phoenix Marco.
There is also the silent involvement of the CP0 organization. The biggest difference of this war is that it is not broadcast live because Wano is a completely isolated country from the world. Therefore, every detail of the battle was reported from the eyewitness present.
The tension on both battlefields is at its peak as powerful characters are fighting for their own survival, the free lives of their friends, and their desire to change the world.
Scales and battles
Since the war in Wano revolved around the Straw Hats, individual battles were more focused. In addition, the crew members also have plenty of time to practice and improve their combat skills before the raid to increase their chances of victory.
Despite many obstacles, in the end, the Straw Hat crew members all had a fight with an Allstar or Topiroppo of the Beast gang and got victory over the enemy.
As a result, the war gradually changed in favor of the alliance of pirates and Samurai. This is a great luck for them because as long as Kaido or a high-ranking commander under him is still standing, the Beasts gang will have many opportunities to turn the situation around.
Whoever the winner is, the confrontation between the characters in this war has depth, not only overwhelming viewers with superior moves but also making it easier for them to follow the progress of the war.
In contrast, the Battle of Summit at Marineford was more chaotic. With so many strong characters on stage, the audience could not enjoy the top-notch battles on a large scale battle scene.
For example, Crocodile had to save Portgas D. Ace from execution while fighting Diamond Jozu. The author only arranged for them to have brief skirmishes to spend time focusing on important developments of the war.
On the other hand, neither the navy nor the pirates wanted to prolong their time on the battlefield, but actively put all their strength into overcoming the dense enemy force.
However, most of the characters are shown their own strength and skills. The audience has witnessed the level and level of the forces in the New World through the dominance of Whitebeard on the battlefield and the absolute strength of the Admirals.
Emotions welling up in battle
In both wars, Luffy was under a lot of pressure with heavy burdens on his shoulders. In Marineford, he had to fight for his brother’s life. In Wano, Luffy’s motivation is his friends who have been oppressed by Kaido for a long time
If it fails, the Straw Hat captain will lose a lot of important things. Unfortunately, he failed to save his brother in Marineford. This was the first time Luffy had lost a loved one and the pain was so great that he fainted on the battlefield.
As for the rest of the characters, their feelings before the battle were no better and even became increasingly desperate in the moment of losing loved ones.
The Godfather and the pirates in the crew all try to fight to save Ace, whom they see as a blood brother and an important part of the great family called Whitebeard.
In Wano, Kaido caused much suffering to the people, causing their families and friends to perish from hunger, poverty, and exhaustion from forced labor.
His actions and the name Orochi made the Samurai burn day and night with the will to take revenge and wait for the right time to stand up and fight.
In the end, thanks to strong allies such as the Straw Hats, the Minks, and the unity of all the Samurai across the country, they prepared their weapons and gathered their forces to raid Onigashima with the determination to turn the tide. down the Yonko Kaido and the Beasts gang.
By knowing the characters’ fighting motivations, the audience can immerse themselves in the emotions of the battle and cheer for the Whitebeard Pirates or the Samurai in Wano to regain what is theirs.
It is difficult to say which battle contains more emotions because both show human meanings and attract viewers to every detail.
The end of the war
Surely both wars will have different results. The summit battle could have ended with the end for the Whitebeard Pirates because the advantage was completely in favor of the navy after the death of the Godfather.
However, the chaos at Marineford was interrupted by Marshall D. Teach and ended abruptly with the arrival of Shanks.
In contrast, Arc Wano had a brighter ending with a resounding victory over the alliance of two Yonko. The Straw Hat Pirates defeated all of the Beast’s deadliest enemies while Law and Kid teamed up to defeat Big Mom.
The defeat of the Whitebeard Pirates at Marineford brought mourning to the greats, and the victory at Wano marked an important milestone and ushered in a new era for the era of pirates.
Where is the greatest battle?
After analyzing all of the above, the war at Wano probably couldn’t match Marineford in terms of chaos and the title Battle of the Summit proved that to be true.
The raid on Onigashima developed in the opposite direction and followed the standard structure of an Arc. The battle between the two factions breaks out and the Straw Hats must manage to overcome various obstacles before facing their final enemy.
The result was not unexpected, each member of the crew won against difficult opponents. The only difference between the characters’ battles is that they take place on a much larger scale than the previous Arcs.
The fight has left many impressions on the audience such as the reveal of Luffy’s real Devil Fruit or the fear of Haki Conqueror. However, the young pirates’ ability to change the world is the greatest thing that Arc Wano has done.
This is not to say that the world was not affected by the Battle of the Summit at Marineford. Although the world has changed dramatically, with the two years of Timeskip taking place, audiences may not have realized the true impact of the battle.
With the truths are gradually being revealed, it is likely that there will be a great battle between the most powerful and superior forces in all aspects.
You have finished reading the article One Piece: The battle of the summit or the raid on Onigashima is more interestingPlease refer to other articles in the same category Anime Rankings Please!
